Archive for the ‘Ben Bernanke’ Category

Another Mention of The Great Depression

Monday, August 3rd, 2009

On July 26th Ben Bernanke said, “”I was not going to be the Federal Reserve chairman who presided over the second Great Depression.”  The quote and associated details can be found here:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124865498517982625.html

I found the quote interesting primarily as it once again underscores the popularity (or should I say fixation) that many people, including prominent economists, have in comparing (and associating the characteristics of) our current period of economic weakness with that of The Great Depression.  As I wrote in my July 13th post, I think that viewing the two periods similarly is not only incorrect but perilous.

SPX at 987.48 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

James Hamilton’s Comment on Ben Bernanke

Thursday, July 2nd, 2009

I found this blog post from James Hamilton to be interesting:

http://www.econbrowser.com/archives/2009/06/on_grilling_the.html

especially when he says this:

“But it is another matter to question Bernanke’s intellect or personal integrity. As someone who’s known him for 25 years, I would place him above 99.9% of those recently in power in Washington on the integrity dimension, not to mention IQ. His actions over the past two years have been guided by one and only one motive, that being to minimize the harm caused to ordinary people by the financial turmoil. Whether you agree or disagree with all the steps he’s taken, let’s start with an understanding that that’s been his overriding goal.”

___

I like to think of the role of the Fed Chairman in a different light, especially with our current economic situation.  I believe that perhaps the two most pertinent questions are:

1.  Does Ben Bernanke have a full understanding of the economic situation we find ourselves in?

2.  What can (and should) he do about it?  Especially considering the concepts of Sustainable Prosperity and America’s Economic Future? (both of which have been extensively referenced on this blog)

SPX at 900.4 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Is Ben Bernanke a “Hero”?

Monday, June 29th, 2009

Recently various people have given high marks and effusive praise for Ben Bernanke’s performance during the Financial Crisis.  Here is a sampling:

“Bernanke’s Handling of US Crisis Gets Strong Mark” :

http://www.cnbc.com/id/31400566

 

From Jack Welch:

“I think he saved the system, I think he’s a national hero,” Welch said. “I think Bernanke seems to be a guy operating on a clear intellectual framework. This guy’s done a hell of a good job.”

http://www.cnbc.com/id/31423019

 

Attributed to Abby Joseph Cohen:

“She also said that history is likely to show that Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke has been an “extraordinarily effective” leader during the current crisis, the worst U.S. recession since World War Two.”

http://tinyurl.com/ml68ja

 

From Warren Buffett:

“The urgency has moved away from a total meltdown of the financial sector which we faced last fall.  I’ve never seen anything like that.  But I would give enormous credit to the people there.  (Federal Reserve Chairman) Bernanke did a fabulous job.”

http://www.cnbc.com/id/31526815/

 

There are other examples as well.  I could comment extensively regarding this praise and “high marks” for Bernanke, and might do so in the future.

However, for now perhaps the main question that comes to mind is whether by commenting in this fashion these people are presupposing that The Financial Crisis is over and that we are indelibly on the road to recovery?

SPX at 918.90 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Are We Avoiding a Depression?

Monday, June 22nd, 2009

Perhaps the most common refrain heard with regard to our current economic situation, and why it won’t become a Depression, is that we as a nation have been proactive and aggressive in “managing” this period of economic weakness. 

This theory, more or less, has the following generalized (and summarized) structure:

  1. There has been rigorous research conducted on the causes of The Great Depression.
  2. Ben Bernanke is widely proclaimed as an expert on The Great Depression era.
  3. Through the knowledge derived through the extensive research of The Great Depression, as well as Ben Bernanke’s expertise of the era, we (as a nation) have a thorough understanding of the causes of The Great Depression, and how that period could have been better managed, if not avoided either fully or in part.
  4. During our current period of economic weakness, widely called “The Economic Crisis” (or “Financial Crisis”), we (as a nation) have been very proactive in deploying various intervention measures that would have avoided The Great Depression and therefore will act to help us avoid a Depression.

I question a variety of the assumptions above.  Additionally, and perhaps most importantly, is our current economic predicament analogous to that of The Great Depression?  While there are certain similarities, there appear to be notable differences as well.  Plus, just the time differential alone would appear to make comparisons difficult.

If the two periods are fundamentally different, why are people apt to compare them?  While this is difficult to answer, it may be (at least in part) because Americans have few periods of severe economic weakness to reference, especially over the last 100 years or so.  If this is correct, it may also call into question the appropriateness of comparisons between this period and The Great Depression.

With regard to whether we, as a nation, have a thorough knowledge of The Great Depression, has been questioned by some.  If our current period of economic weakness is not comparable to that of The Great Depression, it becomes more of an ”academic question” as “lessons learned” from The Great Depression would not necessarily be applicable to the situation we now face.

Furthermore, if our current period of economic weakness is not comparable to that of The Great Depression, the main concern becomes whether our intervention efforts, that purportedly would have avoided The Great Depression, will help us avoid going into our own Depression.

As one can see from the above, I think there are considerable questions that can, and should, be raised with regard to the widely held aforementioned theory and generalized structure presented.

 SPX at 904.99 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Managing Economic Uncertainty

Friday, June 19th, 2009

A couple of days ago I posted excerpts of a speech by Ben Bernanke in which he outlines various reasons for inherent uncertainty and difficulty in economic predictions and forecasts.

It appears that ever since the start of The Financial Crisis, in early 2007, it has been very difficult for forecasters to accurately predict economic performance.   For those interested, I have compiled numerous examples of this, which can be found under the “Predictions” title under the “Articles” heading here:

http://www.economicgreenfield.com/prosperitybypencom-directory/

In light of this inherent uncertainty (and what some may call inability) of economic forecasting, and by extension efforts to “manage” the economy, how can this uncertainty be best managed given that the country has embarked on such a large, and expansive, intervention  (including bailouts, guaranteed loans, stimulus plans, etc.) effort?

Months ago I put together a framework on how to best manage the risks and uncertainties inherent in the various intervention measures.  Just like businesses can successfully manage business plan risk, our country can, and should, seek to manage risks inherent in the various intervention measures. 

The article is entitled “Business Planning Principles Applied to the Stimulus / Intervention Efforts” and can be found under the “Articles” heading here :

http://www.economicgreenfield.com/prosperitybypencom-directory/

Please note this is not necessarily an endorsement of these intervention efforts; it is suggestions as to how best manage the efforts as the stimulus/interventions are put into effect.

SPX at 926.51 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Ben Bernanke – Notable Speech Passages

Wednesday, June 17th, 2009

For those who didn’t read Ben Bernanke’s Commencement Address to The Boston College School of Law on May 22, I would like to highlight a few passages.  I found the passages below informative and telling; I will let them speak for themselves, and might refer back to them in future posts. 

The entire speech can be found here:

http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/bernanke20090522a.htm

_____

“Instead, I’d like to offer a few thoughts today about the inherent unpredictability of our individual lives and how one might go about dealing with that reality.  As an economist and policymaker, I have plenty of experience in trying to foretell the future, because policy decisions inevitably involve projections of how alternative policy choices will influence the future course of the economy.  The Federal Reserve, therefore, devotes substantial resources to economic forecasting.  Likewise, individual investors and businesses have strong financial incentives to try to anticipate how the economy will evolve.  With so much at stake, you will not be surprised to know that, over the years, many very smart people have applied the most sophisticated statistical and modeling tools available to try to better divine the economic future.  But the results, unfortunately, have more often than not been underwhelming.  Like weather forecasters, economic forecasters must deal with a system that is extraordinarily complex, that is subject to random shocks, and about which our data and understanding will always be imperfect.  In some ways, predicting the economy is even more difficult than forecasting the weather, because an economy is not made up of molecules whose behavior is subject to the laws of physics, but rather of human beings who are themselves thinking about the future and whose behavior may be influenced by the forecasts that they or others make.  To be sure, historical relationships and regularities can help economists, as well as weather forecasters, gain some insight into the future, but these must be used with considerable caution and healthy skepticism.”

also:

“The financial crisis that began in August 2007 is the most severe since the Great Depression, and it has been the principal cause of the global recession that began last fall.  Battling that crisis and trying to mitigate its effect on the U.S. and global economies has dominated my waking hours now for some 21 months.  My colleagues at the Fed and I have been called on to take many tough decisions, including adopting extraordinary and unprecedented policy measures to address the crisis.”

also:

“At the same time, because I appreciate the role of chance and contingency in human events, I try to be appropriately realistic about my own capabilities.  I know there is much that I don’t know.  I consequently try to be attentive to all points of view, to work collaboratively, and to involve as many smart people in policy decisions as possible.  Fortunately, my colleagues and the staff at the Federal Reserve are outstanding.  And indeed, many of them have demonstrated their own breadth and flexibility, moving well beyond their previous training and experience to tackle a wide range of novel and daunting issues, usually with great success.”

also:

“You are lucky also to be living and studying in the United States.  There is a lot of pessimistic talk now about the future of America’s economy and its role in the world.  Such talk accompanies every period of economic weakness.  The United States endured a decade-long Great Depression and returned to prosperity and global leadership.  When I graduated from college in 1975, and from graduate school in 1979, the economy was sputtering, gas prices and inflation were high, and  pessimism–malaise, President Carter called it–was rampant.  The U.S. economy subsequently entered more than two decades of growth and prosperity.  The economy will recover–it has too many fundamental strengths to be kept down for too long–and the mood will brighten.”

SPX at 908.7 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

In Ben We Trust?

Wednesday, June 10th, 2009

I will comment frequently on Ben Bernanke, due to his position, but perhaps more importantly, because of his stated theories, beliefs, and ideologies.  It seems to me that the handling of The Financial Crisis certainly has the “fingerprints” of Ben Bernanke all over it.  In fact, I believe that perhaps no other person’s ideologies have ever played such an outsized role in the U.S. economy (and various other global economies) than those of Ben Bernanke.  In my opinion, the U.S. economy (and many financial markets) since The Financial Crisis, can be viewed as an ideologically-levered extension of Ben Bernanke’s beliefs and understandings.

Is this a good thing?  It gets back to two central themes of this blog; are we heading toward Sustainable Prosperity? And will America’s Economic Future be one of an Economic Greenfield or Economic Brownfield?

As for me, I will let my writings speak for themselves with regard to our handling of The Financial Crisis.   As one can guess, I do respect his background, and believe that he has an exceedingly difficult position; but I don’t necessarily concur with many of his theories, interpretations, or actions.

SPX at 939.35 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Bernanke’s June 3 testimony

Monday, June 8th, 2009

Ben Bernanke testified before a House committee on June 3.  Although it doesn’t appear as if he said anything new or different from his previous public statements, I found one statement to be significant.  It is bolded below:

“We continue to expect overall economic activity to bottom out, and then to turn up later this year….An important caveat is that our forecast also assumes continuing gradual repair of the financial system and an associated improvement in credit conditions; a relapse in the financial sector would be a significant drag on economic activity and could cause the incipient recovery to stall.

He has stated this “caveat” in various ways recently.  I find it to be interesting, if not a little puzzling.  In my opinion, it is almost like saying, “It will be sunny tommorrow, unless it rains.” 

I’m not sure as to his reason for including this phrase, but I think it significant nonetheless…

SPX at 930.96 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark

Ben Bernanke quote

Friday, June 5th, 2009

I saw this quote in Charles Schwab’s “On Investing” magazine, Summer 2009 page 6.  It is attributed to Ben Bernanke:

“Over the years, the U.S. economy has shown a remarkable ability to absorb shocks of all kinds, to recover, and to continue to grow.”

I’m not trying to single out Ben Bernanke with regard to this quote, as we’ve heard this general theme, with numerous permutations,  repeated countlessly by others. 

However, I feel the concept itself is significant.  To me, it is indicative of complacency and seems to downplay the importance of decision making and analysis.  Every time I hear this concept repeated it causes me to cringe.

SPX at 937.8 as this post is written

  • Share/Bookmark